logo

My Handcrafted Opinions on Whiskies, Distilleries and Other Related Stuff

Most Recent Whisky

Most Recent Whisky Review

Woodford Reserve Distillers Select Straight Rye

This bottle was labelled #3031 from Batch 0887 and bottled at 45.2% ABV.  The nose was very nice, herbal tea with mint and sweet vanilla notes.  The mouthfeel is fresh, light and oily, bittersweet on palate with more vanilla, candy, black coffee and dark chocolate.  The finish has peppermint, wood and grassy rye notes.  With water it gets sweeter, even honeyed, while heat builds in the finish with chilli spiced dark chocolate.  Overall very delicious; a light and subtle of straight rye.

Read More
  • Simon Seaton

    Simon Seaton

    Saturday, 10 December 2011 01:52

    Sazerac Rye 18 year old (Fall 2011)

    What a nose... the rye really comes through and also some sweetness and a note of fresh paint.  The taste is also sweet, with corn and then the rye again.  It's very smooth.  Some pepper in the finish which hangs around for quite a long time, quite drying and even in the finish the rye can be detected.  This is so unlike other whiskies I find it hard to describe all the flavors so I just recommend just sitting back enjoying it.

    Saturday, 10 December 2011 01:44

    Glenfarclas 105

    They say you never forget your first.... cask strength whisky.  And this was mine.  At 60% ABV, the nose is dominated by alcohol and then hints of the sherry butts.  Lots of fruity, classic Speyside notes.  The taste neat is alcohol at first and then as that fades the sherry comes through, dried fruits, christmas cake are all there and then a long, very smooth finish.  Like the Aberlour a'bunadh, the spirit dominates this, wood takes a back seat.  With water (which I think this needs) some wood notes start to come through in a long dry, sherry finish.    Did I mention the sherry?
    Saturday, 10 December 2011 01:37

    Black Grouse

    One of those great ideas from the marketing boys that has potential disaster written all over it... think New Coke.  Take the much loved Famous Grouse blend and beef it up with smokey, peaty Islay malts to create the Black Grouse.  Well in this case kudos to the marketing boys.  The nose of course has the peat smoke but also the Famous Grouse honey sweetness and a hint of chocolate.  The taste is exactly what you would expect, honey sweet and then peat smoke, but well balanced and restrained enough to avoid drowning the honey.  There are also some rich notes, I susepct they beefed up the malts in this blend to stand up to the peat.   Balanced and very good value (I paid $24 in duty free for 1L).
    Friday, 09 December 2011 15:51

    Ballantine's Finest

    More great blending work.  The nose is fruity and creamy, with bananas and lemon.  The taste is sweet, caramel, lemon, vanilla and some biscuit and the mouth feel is light and creamy.  It is almost like a dessert with the sweet lemon, cream and a biscuit crumb.  Has a nice lemony finish and finally some oak and more woody notes come through at the end.
    Friday, 09 December 2011 15:25

    Royal Salute 100 Casks

    Another really solid, but not great, blend from the Chivas stable.  The nose was very nice, I got chocolate, sherry and maybe even some cherries.  The taste was very smooth and well rounded,  Hard to pick a lot out of it, but it was good.  Some oak in the finish, but it was not harsh, and some spice as well, ginger and pepper and hint of smoke.  Everything was balanced.

    Friday, 09 December 2011 15:19

    Chivas Regal 12 year old

    I liked this one.  The nose has cereals and malt, dried fruits and maybe banana and a fresh paint or furniture polish note.  The taste was smooth and quite sweet with toffee, vanilla and banana and oak.  Oak also in the finish, drying, perhaps with a slight bitter note like baker's chocolate.  Considering its availability and price, this is a great value product.
    Wednesday, 07 December 2011 19:41

    Bushmills 16 year old

    The nose was sweet, candy even, or maple syrup, sherry and even acetone.  This has the signature Irish smoothness and the taste had licorice, fruit and berries, even grape juice, and sweetness.  A nice finish with oak and tannic notes.  I have tried this on a few occasions (once in the The Old Bushmills Inn, in Bushmills, the night before I visted the Old Bushmills Distillery) and the most recent tasting I did to get these notes was not quite what I expected.  I will come back to this one.... didn't change my rating, this is still a solid 3 star whisky, just not quite what I remembered.

    Wednesday, 07 December 2011 00:36

    Famous Grouse 12 year old Gold Reserve

    The nose has honey and malt and quite soft.  The taste has honey and oaky spices, rich and warming with some floral notes.  The finish is quite spicy and a hint of smoke, while honey keeps coming through, like a hot toddy, perhaps the perfect whisky to sip with cold.  Very similar taste profile to the standard Famous Grouse, honeyed, spice, oak and hint of smoke, but everything is dialled up and rich.   Do not mistake this for a "just another blended scotch" and I would guess it would trip up a few people in blind tastings. 
    Wednesday, 07 December 2011 00:27

    Glenfiddich 12 year old

    There is a reason this is one of the world best selling single malts.  It's good.  Nose is malty, dried fruit and maybe a hint of polished wood.  The taste is warming and rich and has cinnamon spice.  Complex and balanced with honey, dried fruits, chocolate biscuit, raisins and maybe sherry. The finish is dry and woody.
    Tuesday, 06 December 2011 01:08

    Kilchoman (2010 Winter Release)

    A great place to visit, see my entry under Distilleries.  This release is very pale which reflects probably only 3 years in a cask.  The nose has peat, pepper and some vanilla.  The taste is licorice, tobacco and some spices and it has a drying, peaty finish.  A little unbalanced for me, could use more sweet notes, and not overly complex.  It does sweeten a little with water but then more bitter oak notes come through as well.  I have no doubt this is going to be a good one, but is still young.

    Whiskies Tried...

    Total to Date: 694

    Distilleries

    Visited to Date: 66

    Follow Me on Twitter!

    Random Whisky

    Glenmorangie Astar

    I first tried this natural strength expression at a Glenmorangie tasting led by Dr Bill Lumsden in Austin in 2012.  This expression is supposed to showcase their classic wood policy, summarized as "slow growth, air seasoned, heavy toasted, light char ex-bourbon barrels".  The nose has mint, alcohol and some spices.  The taste is bold, more of the mint and alcohol from the nose, a silky mouthfeel and some vanilla and aniseed.  The finish has more herbal notes and is long and lingering.  Really good and something I will be going back to.